TY - UNPB
T1 - Anekdotisk teori som videnskabsteori
T2 - – i socialpædagogik og andre relationelle professioner
AU - Secher, Marianne Træbing
PY - 2026/5/19
Y1 - 2026/5/19
N2 - Anecdotes circulate widely in professional practice, yet they are rarely granted epistemic status. They are shared and discussed but seldom recognized as legitimate contributions to knowledge production. In common usage, an anecdote is simply a small story; in this article, however, I focus on a specific kind of anecdote that contains an exorbitant moment in which practice breaks down and something falls outside the problem definition embedded in a given theory or method. This theoretical understanding is developed in dialogue with Jane Gallop’s anecdotal theory, originally formulated in literary studies. I transfer and further develop this theory in a social pedagogical context and argue that anecdotal theory can function as a profession-specific contribution to philosophy of science. Here, the anecdote is not treated as an illustrative example but as an epistemic rupture that makes a form of theoretical and methodological self-limitation necessary. The practitioner must be able to temporarily bracket established theories and methods when the other’s utterance challenges their frame, so that the relation is not prematurely closed through rapid theoretical or methodological integration. While the argument is grounded in social pedagogy, the approach may be relevant in other relational disciplines as well.
AB - Anecdotes circulate widely in professional practice, yet they are rarely granted epistemic status. They are shared and discussed but seldom recognized as legitimate contributions to knowledge production. In common usage, an anecdote is simply a small story; in this article, however, I focus on a specific kind of anecdote that contains an exorbitant moment in which practice breaks down and something falls outside the problem definition embedded in a given theory or method. This theoretical understanding is developed in dialogue with Jane Gallop’s anecdotal theory, originally formulated in literary studies. I transfer and further develop this theory in a social pedagogical context and argue that anecdotal theory can function as a profession-specific contribution to philosophy of science. Here, the anecdote is not treated as an illustrative example but as an epistemic rupture that makes a form of theoretical and methodological self-limitation necessary. The practitioner must be able to temporarily bracket established theories and methods when the other’s utterance challenges their frame, so that the relation is not prematurely closed through rapid theoretical or methodological integration. While the argument is grounded in social pedagogy, the approach may be relevant in other relational disciplines as well.
KW - Undersøgelsesdesign, teori og metode
M3 - Working paper
BT - Anekdotisk teori som videnskabsteori
ER -